SearchsearchUseruser

Mahler: Symphonies 1–9 - Bychkov

Mahler: Symphonies 1–9 - Bychkov

PentaTone Classics  PTC5187490

Stereo  (11 hours 48 minutes)

Classical - Orchestral


Christiane Karg, Sarah Wegener, Kateřina Kněžíková, Miriam Kutrowatz (soprano)
Catriona Morison, Jennifer Johnston, Stefanie Irányi (mezzo-soprano)
Elisabeth Kulman (alto)
David Butt Philip (tenor)
Adam Plachetka (baritone)
David Steffens (bass)
Pueri gaudentes
Prague Philharmonic Children's Choir
Prague Philharmonic Choir
Czech Philharmonic Choir of Brno
Czech Philharmonic Orchestra
Semyon Bychkov (conductor)


PENTATONE’s release of the Czech Philharmonic’s complete Mahler Cycle under Bychkov brings together one of Europe’s most historically resonant orchestras with a conductor internationally recognised for his structural command and interpretive integrity. The Orchestra occupies a distinctive place within Mahler’s geographical and cultural landscape – Mahler was born and brought up in Bohemia and completed his first symphony shortly after spending a year in Prague. Mahler symphonies have been central to Bychkov’s programming with the Czech Philharmonic since 2018 when he opened his tenure as Chief Conductor and Music Director with performances of Mahler Symphony No. 2.

Symphonies Nos. 1–5, released by PENTATONE beginning in April 2022, have received universal acclaim. The recordings have been selected as Gramophone Editor’s Choice and BBC Music Magazine Recording of the Month. As The Sunday Times writes, “This is turning out to be one of the truly great Mahler sets.”

Available for streaming and/or download in Hi-Res from these services:

Listen on Presto Music Listen/buy on Qobuz

Add to your wish list | library

 

1 of 2 recommend this, would you recommend it?  yes | no

All
show
Comments (9)
show
hide

Comment by hiredfox - April 10, 2026 (1 of 9)

Is this misleading? There are no SACDs only CDs as far as my understanding goes.

Comment by Stephen Best - April 10, 2026 (2 of 9)

Correct. See my comments here:

Pépin: Les Eaux Célestes - Orchestre national de Lyon, Glassberg

Comment by breydon_music - April 10, 2026 (3 of 9)

I am afraid I am with hiredfox here - I find the listing of items which are not on any form of hi-res physical disc misleading to say the least. My impression, as someone who doesn't have the slightest interest in streaming or downloading, is that a very great deal of recorded material indeed is available in higher resolution in this way from one vendor or another. However this is a site devoted to physical hi-res discs, and to suddenly start littering it with a few randomly selected virtual items seems as pointless as it is misleading and annoying. Having said that, I am sure that it is here to stay and simply the thin end of a very big wedge, since everything the site owner has wanted to do in the past he has done, irrespective of anyone else's opinion.

Comment by SACD-MAN (threerandot) - April 11, 2026 (4 of 9)

Sad to see what is happening to physical media on presto. Very disappointing. pentatone is also a disappointment. I guess this is a reflection of what consumers want? Or are these releases just there to save money for presto and the big labels? I really miss being in a store where people are also buying a physical disc or album where that human connection happens. Vinyl is there in stores but classical music on disc... are they trying to get us to buy a download instead of an actual disc? This is not a good time for classical music fans to buy a disc. Sad.

Comment by Peter Martin - April 14, 2026 (5 of 9)

The listing clearly states “DIGITAL”. It is high(ish) res (24/96) and can be purchased as a download from Presto or Qobuz for those who do not like to stream. I much prefer to do that than pay an inflated price for a SACD from companies like Chandos where their master is only 24/96 to begin with. As for talk of “misleading”, I consider PCM-recorded SACDs to be a prime example of misleading consumers.

Comment by Graham Williams - April 15, 2026 (6 of 9)

The word DIGITAL has, helpfully, only just been added by the site owner to avoid confusion.

Why single out Chandos for criticism when, for example, the new Walton Symphonies release on DGG costs £ 14 for the CD and £22.19 for the Hi-Res lossless download (24/96)? Surely an inflated price? The Pentatone Mahler cycle costs £54.25 for the CDs and £83.04 for the downloads (24/96) no packaging, no printed booklets. Progress?

Comment by breydon_music - April 15, 2026 (7 of 9)

I agree with Graham's points. Perhaps the previous contributor simply prefers virtual carriers to physical ones, which is fair enough - it's a free world. But we SACD supporters must surely support and encourage the hard core of companies who maintain a commitment to physical hi-res.

I suspect though, ultimately, this decision has been driven by the need to make the site pay for itself. Income from buying links must have declined over the years, and presumably Presto are offering a financial incentive to having their service promoted here.

That's just the realities of life, and if that's it, I have no issue with that.

Comment by DYB - April 24, 2026 (8 of 9)

My comment is on the performances. I've seen Bychkov live in opera houses (well, the Metropolitan in NYC, conducting multiple operas) and with symphony orchestras. And I've listened to many of his recordings. And I want to like him, but he always leaves me bored. It's the same with several of these Mahler symphonies from this cycle. Carefully prepared, beautifully played, maybe even thoughtful, and with the personality of a doorknob. It's just how Bychkov always leaves me.

Comment by SACD-MAN (threerandot) - Today 03:23 am (9 of 9)

Does the download trend reflect what consumers actually want? Whenever changes happen like this, I wonder how much of it is a reflection of what customers want, or is it imposed? Do we have any numbers or data about this shift? After all, classical music is an older crowd that I think would prefer physical media. Does anyone have any insights on this?