In my first comment, I pointed out a few small differences in this SACD release compared to previous Universal Japan editions. Now it seems there's another interesting ...
A remarkable job has been done with the 55 year old master tape here.
It was very well recorded to begin with, but Rob LoVerde and Shawn R. Britton have combined brilliantly ...
It seems that the plight of the industry has also been reflected in BIS's recording preferences, especially for releases in the last six months (which were, however, recorded ...
Rachmaninoff’s first symphony is prone to obtaining contradictory appreciation. DYB's pertinent comments prompted me to listen once more to Gabriel Feltz and his Dortmunder ...
4 of 5 recommend this, would you recommend it? yes | no
All
Comments (1)
Comment by aubullience - December 7, 2023 (1 of 1)
Caveat Emptor- while Monk's playing on this disc is exemplary, as one would expect, in my systems the sound of the issue has a very marked stridency in the mid-treble range, even (albeit to a much lesser extent) in my secondary system, which skews slightly 'dark in its presentation. For (limited) reference, my primary system has Vivid Speakers, and contains a tube preamp offering a slight degree of added warmth; and for my secondary one, a fairly neutral-balanced Ayre disc player and electronics feeding into an old pair of Monitor Audios (which account that bit of darkness/warmth). Both listening rooms are slightly under-damped, but again, this disc is an outlier for me in terms of the aforementioned stridency to its high end. It's the only SACD for which I've ever had this problem to date (out of a few hundred I own), and perhaps the only disc of any kind with which I've had this problem in my secondary system. While the sonic defect could conceivably exist in other formats (I own neither a cd nor lp version of this recording) over the past thirty five yearsI've had my share of plenty of Monk recordings in LP, cd and SACD format, none of them displaying this kind of tonal balance.
Related (7)
Click here to report errors or omissions in the music details.
Comment by aubullience - December 7, 2023 (1 of 1)
Caveat Emptor- while Monk's playing on this disc is exemplary, as one would expect, in my systems the sound of the issue has a very marked stridency in the mid-treble range, even (albeit to a much lesser extent) in my secondary system, which skews slightly 'dark in its presentation. For (limited) reference, my primary system has Vivid Speakers, and contains a tube preamp offering a slight degree of added warmth; and for my secondary one, a fairly neutral-balanced Ayre disc player and electronics feeding into an old pair of Monitor Audios (which account that bit of darkness/warmth). Both listening rooms are slightly under-damped, but again, this disc is an outlier for me in terms of the aforementioned stridency to its high end. It's the only SACD for which I've ever had this problem to date (out of a few hundred I own), and perhaps the only disc of any kind with which I've had this problem in my secondary system. While the sonic defect could conceivably exist in other formats (I own neither a cd nor lp version of this recording) over the past thirty five yearsI've had my share of plenty of Monk recordings in LP, cd and SACD format, none of them displaying this kind of tonal balance.